Sandro Tonali is reportedly favouring a return to AC Milan if he departs Newcastle United this summer, dealing a blow to both Arsenal and Manchester United.
According to TEAMtalk, Milan believe there is still a possible pathway to bring the Italian midfielder back to San Siro, despite Newcastle’s significant asking price.
Newcastle are said to value Tonali at around £100m, making any potential deal extremely difficult for interested clubs to structure.
That enormous price tag alone would present a major obstacle, but the player’s own preference could prove an even bigger barrier for English clubs.
Both Arsenal and Manchester United have been linked with the 26-year-old, with ESPN previously reporting interest from Arsenal, Manchester City, and Manchester United.
Tonali joined Newcastle from AC Milan in 2023 and has since become a highly valued member of the Magpies squad.
Sky Sports reported his contract had been extended until 2029, with an option for a further year, strengthening Newcastle’s negotiating position considerably.
For Arsenal, the midfielder represents an ideal profile, with Mikel Arteta’s side seeking players capable of handling high-pressure matches and delivering control in big games.
Tonali brings Premier League experience alongside those qualities, making him a particularly attractive option for a club with genuine title ambitions.
Manchester United face an equally frustrating picture, as the Red Devils are actively searching for midfield upgrades and have shown strong interest in the Newcastle star.
Milan are reportedly exploring a creative route to reduce the overall cost of a deal, potentially through add-ons or player exchange arrangements.
That kind of flexible structure could give Milan a genuine advantage over Premier League rivals who would need to meet Newcastle’s full valuation in more straightforward terms.
Player preference has a well-established history of proving decisive in transfer negotiations, and Tonali’s emotional connection to Milan should not be underestimated by any pursuing club.
If Tonali’s heart remains set on a San Siro homecoming, Arsenal and United may find themselves fighting a losing battle regardless of the financial packages they are willing to offer.
